Bloomberg defamation trial: Verdict reserved after court hears closing submissions
https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/tan-see-leng-shanmugam-defamation-low-de-wei-bloomberg-closing-submissions-6133906?cid=internal_sharetool_androidphone_22052026_cna
The provided report details the closing submissions in the defamation trial brought by Home Affairs and Law Minister K Shanmugam and Manpower Minister Tan See Leng against Bloomberg and its reporter Low De Wei.
The High Court wrapped up the seven-day trial on Friday, May 22, 2026. Here are the key highlights:
Case Background
- The Article: The lawsuit centers on a December 12, 2024, Bloomberg article titled "Singapore Mansion Deals Are Increasingly Shrouded in Secrecy."
- The Allegation: The ministers claim the article defamed them by suggesting they conducted property transactions (Good Class Bungalows or GCBs) in an opaque manner, taking advantage of a lack of checks and balances.
Core Arguments
- The Ministers' Position (represented by Senior Counsel Davinder Singh):
- Argued that the article falsely linked the ministers' transactions to secrecy, weak oversight, and money laundering concerns.
- Accused the defendants of "unprecedented" malice, pointing to Bloomberg's decision to remove the paywall for the story and publicly stand by it.
- Maintained that the defense of "responsible journalism" does not apply under Singapore law in this context.
- Bloomberg's Position (represented by Senior Counsel Sreenivasan Narayanan):
- Argued the article was a legitimate piece of public interest journalism regarding transparency trends in the real estate market.
- Claimed there was no malice involved and that the report relied on a "plain and ordinary" reading of facts.
- Contended that while property information is technically available via government databases (INLIS), it remains difficult and costly for the general public to access.
Damages and Next Steps
- Sought Damages: The ministers are seeking a higher amount of damages than the S$420,000 recently awarded in a separate defamation case against Terry Xu (editor of The Online Citizen) regarding the same issue.
- Verdict: Justice Audrey Lim has reserved her verdict. No specific date has been set for the final judgment.
The ministers were not present in court during the closing submissions.